Contrasting and Exploring the “Evil Human Nature” in Chinese and Western Thought: A Comparative Analysis of Xunzi and Augustine
Abstract
The topic of human nature has always been a significant issue in the field of philosophy, and the process of exploring human nature has revealed cultural differences between the East and the West. This study adopts a comparative approach to analyze the differences in the theory of "evil human nature" between Xunzi and St. Augustine, as well as the cultural disparities reflected in these differences. Through a comparative analysis, three main points of divergence between the two thinkers reflect the cultural differences between Eastern and Western civilizations: the manner in which individuals convert evil nature into goodness, the divergence in the choice of free will, and equality among individuals. These differences ultimately reflect the cultural disparities between Eastern and Western civilizations, with Confucianism and Christianity representing their respective traditions. However, it is undeniable that both Xunzi and Augustine aimed to encourage virtuous conduct and establish a harmonious society permeated by goodness.
References
- An, X. L. (2007). The Classic Collection of Chinese Literature: Xunzi. Zhonghua Book Company, Beijing, China.
- Tan, Y. G. (2018). Mind as The Expounder of and Practice as The Fulfillment of Goodness: A New Approach to Xunzi’s Theory of Human Nature. Master's thesis, East China Normal University.
- Wang, H. (2022). The Theory of 'Nature and Acquired effort': Xunzi's Thoughts on Human Nature Shaping and the Path of Shaping Chinese Characteristics Socialism. Journal of Mudanjiang Institute of Education, 11, 117-120.
- Song, W. H. and Zhang, X. D. (2016). A Comparative Cultural Study of Evil:Views of Augustine and Xunzi. Journal of Yangzhou University (Humanities and Social Sciences Edition), 20(04), 23-28.
- Zhou, C. C. (2015). The Attribution of “Xing'e” to Xunzi's Disciples: A Study on Liu Xiang's Editing and the Textual Structure of "Xing'e”. Journal of Sun Yat-sen University (Social Sciences Edition), 55(06), 87-95.
- Zhao, L. and Deng, X. M. (2014). Western Philosophy History. Higher Education Press, Beijing, China.
- Augustine. (2018). The City of God (Wang, X. C., Trans). People's Publishing House, Beijing, China.
- Augustine. (1963). Confessionum. (Zhou, S. L., Trans). Commercial Press, Beijing, China.
- Zhao, L. (2006). Sin and Free Will: An Analysis of Augustine's "Original Sin" Theory. World Philosophy, (03), 77-85.
- Battle, J. (1996). How can god be just and ordain evil. Western Reformed Seminary Journal, 3, 1.
- Hu, X. and Guo, J. (2011). Evil Human Nature: From the Perspectives of St. Augustine and Hsun Tzu. Open Journal of Philosophy, 1, 61-66.