Narrating History and Memory: A Comparative Reading of Shujuan and Boku in Geling Yan’s The Flowers of War and Murakami Haruki’s Killing Commendatore
Abstract
According to Pierre Nora’s argument on the relationship between memory and history, these two concepts are not synonyms but antonyms. In the modern world, critical history begins from rational reflection, and it represses memory, which correlates more to the personal narrative field. The memory theory gives us the insight to reexamine the narration in literary works reflecting the war memory. This paper demonstrates different voices in narrating the individualized traumatic memory of the Nanking Massacre through the comparative reading between fictional works of Murakami Haruki and Geling Yan, Killing Commendatore and The Flowers of War. Shujuan, the protagonist in the novella of Yan, is both the observer and survivor of the massacre. Her storyline obtains two heterogeneous narratives that respectively belong to the field of personal memory and history; while her responsibility of memorizing the unrecorded experience makes her to pick a historical view to narrate her past. ‘Boku, ’the first-person protagonist in Murakami’s fiction, on the other hand, is a contemporary character with no experience or direct memory of the war. However, he gets connected with the war memory through the Murakami-style surreal experience. His experience demonstrates how personal memory can console the trauma after the war, usually neglected by the grand history. In the paper, I argue that although the two authors are from different cultural backgrounds and apply different styles, their narrations that focus on the personal memory field show the consoling power that connects the past and present and heals the trauma left by the war. Further, their fictions still contribute to the political and historical discussions on Nanking, presenting the power against revisionists and bridging the conflicts inside the discussions around such a traumatic historical issue.
References
- Berry, Michael. A History of Pain: Trauma in Modern Chinese Literature and Film. Columbia Univ. Press, 2011. pp.110
- T. Yoshida (2009) The Greater East Asian War (Daito A Senso ) [Introduction]. In 2218890354 1522408089 , The making of the "Rape of nanking": History and memory in Japan, China, and the United States. New York: Oxford University Press. pp. 6-7.
- Nora, Pierre. “Between Memory and History: Les Lieux de Mémoire.” Representations, no. 26, 1989, pp. 7.
- Thomson, A., Frisch, M., & Hamilton, P. (1994). The Memory and History Debates: Some International Perspectives. Oral History, 22(2), 33. http://www.jstor.org/stable/40179363
- Herbert Marcuse, The Aesthetic Dimension: Toward a Critique of Marxist Aesthetics (Boston: Beacon Press, 1978), 7–8.
- Stahl, D. C., & Williams, M. (2010). Introducation. In IMAG(in)ing the war in Japan representing and responding to trauma in postwar literature and film. pp.2
- Stahl, D. C., & Williams, M. (2010). Introducation. In IMAG(in)ing the war in Japan representing and responding to trauma in postwar literature and film. pp.3
- Altaher Bassmah Bassam (2017) Geling Yan's The Flowers of War: Bitterness and Sacrifice in Colonized China, Asian Journal of Women's Studies, 23:1, 132-137
- Geling Yan, translated by Nicky Harman The Flowers of War; New York: Other Press, 2012. Ch.1
- Geling Yan, translated by Nicky Harman The Flowers of War; New York: Other Press, 2012. Ch.15
- Matthews, Graham J. "Chinese Historical Fiction in the Wake of Postmodernism: Two Versions of Yan Geling’s The Flowers of War." MFS Modern Fiction Studies, vol. 62 no. 4, 2016, p. 668
- Nora, Pierre. “Between Memory and History: Les Lieux de Mémoire.” Representations, no. 26, 1989, pp.13
- Geling Yan, translated by Nicky Harman The Flowers of War; New York: Other Press, 2012. Prelude
- Stahl, D. C., & Williams, M. (2010). Introducation. In IMAG(in)ing the war in Japan representing and responding to trauma in postwar literature and film, pp.13
- Joshua P. S. Kim (2022) Rethinking Haruki Murakami: An Alternative History of Traumas and Aftermaths in Kafka on the Shore, Critique: Studies in Contemporary Fiction. pp. 9
- Murakami Haruki, Killing Commendatore; New York:Penguin Random House LLC, 2018, Ch.15
- Nora, Pierre. “Between Memory and History: Les Lieux de Mémoire.” Representations, no. 26, 1989, pp.13
- Rubin, J. (2010). Chapter Two. Murakami Haruki and the War Inside. Imag(in)ing the War in Japan, pp. 63
- Murakami Haruki, Killing Commendatore; New York:Penguin Random House LLC, 2018, Prologue