Research Article

Features and Contributing Factors of Tulai in the Mid-Qing Period

Zipeng Qin*
University of Hong Kong

* Corresponding author: [email protected]

Abstract

In legal terms, tulai in the mid-Qing period was marked by pronounced ethical framing rooted in mourning-apparel kinship norms and an emphasis on the status-order system. Socially, it was defined by the instrumental exploitation of corpses and deaths. These characteristics arose from a confluence of multiple factors. At the legal level, the Qing multi-tiered judicial review system furnished critical preconditions that made tulai feasible. The regard for homicide cases was turned into a tool for perpetrators who commits tulai to exert pressure, while loopholes in grassroots judicial practice created further opportunities for activities like tulai. At the social level, growing numbers of social-intermediary groups became involved in tulai. Litigation masters and village headmen stood out most prominently among them. They facilitated or even directly took part in tulai plots by offering legal assistance, intelligence and other forms of support. At the political level, the imperial attention directed toward tulai cases stemmed not only from the emperor's concern for the status-order system, but also from his endeavour to counteract the bureaucratic documentary apparatus. These traits reflect an intricate interplay of multiple interwoven factors. This study would shed light on legal practices in late imperial China and their relationship with the everyday lives of ordinary people.

Keywords: Tulai; Mid-Qing; Litigation Masters; Multi-Tiered Judicial Review System
Published: November 17, 2026
DOI: 10.54254/2753-7064/2026.39117
Volume: CHR Vol.128
pp. 92-102
Download PDF

References

  1. Yang, Y. (2023). Judicial adjudication in Lai Maoduan's capital appeal case of false homicide accusation during the Daoguang reign.Historical Archives, (1), 107-115.
  2. Du, Y. (2019). Policies and counterstrategies: State-sponsored filiality and false accusation in Qing China.International Journal of Asian Studies, 16, 79-97.
  3. Shen, Z. Q. (2000).The Great Qing Statutes with Compiled Commentary (Da Qing lü jizhu). Law Press China. Beijing.
  4. Du, J. J. (2008).Collection of social historical materials from Xingke Tiben of the Jiaqing reign. Tianjin Ancient Books Publishing House. Tianjin.
  5. Xu, Z. Q. (2024).A study of homicide cases concerning mourning hierarchy in the Qing dynasty. Ph.D. thesis, Southwest University of Political Science and Law.
  6. Department of History, Sichuan University & Sichuan Provincial Archives. (1989).Selected archives of Baxian County from the Qianlong, Jiaqing and Daoguang reigns, Qing Dynasty. Sichuan University Press. Chengdu.
  7. Brown, T. (2025). Bureaucracy from the bottom up: Diviners in Qing local governance.Journal of Chinese History, 9(2), 345-378.
  8. Nanchong Municipal Archives of Sichuan Province. (2016).Yamen archives of Nanbu County, Sichuan, Qing Dynasty. Huangshan Publishing House. Hefei.
  9. Chen, L. (2024). Concretising the legal professional community in late imperial China, 1700–1900.Asian Journal of Law and Society, 11(3), 260-287.
  10. Deng, J. P. (2022). Deviations in prefectural and county judicial practice during the Qing Dynasty.The Qing History Journal, (2), 1-12.
  11. Peng, K. X., Lin, Z. (2023). The amendment of central regulations and the governance of the Qing Dynasty: An analysis based on The Great Qing Code and The Collected Statutes and Precedents.Front. Hist. China, 18(2), 221-258.