Communications in Humanities Research ISSN: 2753-7072
Home> Volumes> Volume CHR Vol.124> Article
Research Article

The Formation Pathways, Mechanisms, and Political Functions of the "Sinful Father–Virtuous Son" Narrative in Ancient Chinese Mythology: The Cases of Gun and Yu, and Gonggong and Goulong

Jinhan Yuan*
Northeast Yucai Foreign Language School

* Corresponding author: [email protected]

Abstract

The two pairs—Gun and Yu, and Gonggong and Goulong—exhibit a binary "sinful father–virtuous son" narrative pattern. Through layered textual analysis, this paper traces the formation and development of this narrative from the Western Zhou to the Han dynasties, revealing its processes of character differentiation, deification and political functions. The fathers' images were progressively associated with guilt and transgression, while the sons' identities were increasingly associated with merit and sanctity. As these texts were repeatedly reinterpreted over time, the two father–son pairs gradually became contrasting figures with distinct divine statuses. The paper also identifies two narrative mechanisms, which I call "momentum-building" and "context." In both cases, the fathers' negative identities opened up space for the sons' positive identities and gave them a framework of meaning. Together, these mechanisms turned patrilineal relationships into a way of explaining moral succession and political legitimacy. The study shows how rewriting myth could link kinship, moral values, religious status, and political authority in ancient China.

Keywords: Sinful Father–Virtuous Son; Gun and Yu; Gonggong and Goulong; Textual Accumulation; Political Legitimacy
Published: November 3, 2026
DOI: 10.54254/2753-7064/2026.38454
Volume: CHR Vol.124
pp. 113-119
Download PDF

References

  1. Allan, S. (1991).The shape of the turtle: Myth, art, and cosmos in early China. State University of New York Press. Albany.
  2. Qiu, X. (2002). A study of the inscription on the Suigong Xu vessel.Chinese Historical Artefacts, (6), 13-27.
  3. Cook, C. A. (2013). Sage King Yu and the Suigong Xu.Early China, 35-36, 69-103.
  4. Chen, L. S. (2011). Gun and Yu: Revisiting the Chinese "earth-diver" hypothesis. In Schipper, M., Ye, S. X., Yin, H. B. (Eds.),China's creation and origin myths: Cross-cultural explorations in oral and written traditions(pp. 153-174). Brill.
  5. Lewis, M. E. (2006).The flood myths of early China. State University of New York Press. Albany.
  6. Shangshu. (2009). InThirteen classics with commentaries and annotations. Zhonghua Book Company. Beijing.
  7. Zuo Zhuan. (2009). InThirteen Classics with Commentaries and Annotations. Zhonghua Book Company. Beijing.
  8. Guoyu. (2015). Shanghai Ancient Books Publishing House. Shanghai.
  9. Qu Yuan. (2015).Chu Ci. Zhonghua Book Company. Beijing.
  10. Mencius. (2009). InThirteen Classics with Commentaries and Annotations. Zhonghua Book Company. Beijing.
  11. Liji. (2009). InThirteen Classics with Commentaries and Annotations. Zhonghua Book Company. Beijing.
  12. Allan, S. (2017). The Jishi outburst flood of 1920 BCE and the great flood legend in ancient China: Preliminary reflections.Journal of Chinese Humanities, 3(1), 23–34.
  13. Xunzi. (2012). Zhonghua Book Company. Beijing.
  14. Lüshi Chunqiu. (2011). Zhonghua Book Company. Beijing.
  15. Tian, Z. Y., Ye, S. X., & Qian, H. (2020).Myths of the creation of Chinese. Springer. Singapore.
  16. Sima Qian. (2014).Records of the grand historian. Zhonghua Book Company. Beijing.
  17. Wang Chong. (2018).Lunheng. Zhonghua Book Company. Beijing.
  18. Zhao Ye. (2021).Wu Yue Chunqiu. Zhonghua Book Company. Beijing.
  19. Chen, P. (2014). A comparative study of mythological values in pre-Qin China and ancient Greece. Tianjin People's Publishing House. Tianjin.
  20. Huainanzi. (2012). Zhonghua Book Company. Beijing.
  21. Ban, G. (1962). The book of Han. Zhonghua Book Company. Beijing.
  22. Cai, Y. (2012). Duduan. Zhonghua Book Company. Beijing.
  23. Ying, S. (2010). Fengsu Tongyi. Zhonghua Book Company. Beijing.
  24. Fan, Y. (1965). The book of the later Han. Zhonghua Book Company. Beijing.
  25. Baihu Tong. (1994). In: Chen Li.Commentary and explanation on the Baihu Tong. Zhonghua Book Company. Beijing.
  26. Quan, Y. N. (2010). The ethical narrative of Chinese creation myths.Journal of Baoji University of Arts and Sciences (Social Sciences Edition), 30(6), 46-50.
  27. Yuan, H. (2017).A study of the agrarian divinity in the Shang, Zhou, Qin, and Han dynasties. Social Sciences Academic Press. Beijing.
  28. Puett, M. J. (2002).To become a god: Cosmology, sacrifice, and self-divinization in early China. Harvard University Asia Center. Cambridge, Mass.