"The Little Bird" and "The Old Lover": A Comparative Analysis of the Fates of Nora in "A Doll's House" and Lu Shiping in "Thunderstorm"
Abstract
A Doll's HouseandThunderstormstand as two seminal works in the history of Chinese and Western theater, respectively portraying the deeply memorable female characters Nora and Lu Shiping while depicting the quintessential existential dilemmas faced by women in their respective societies. This paper examines the following questions: What similarities and differences exist in the awakening processes of Nora and Lu Shiping under the apparent oppression of patriarchal families? Why did one choose to "run away", while the other was compelled toward compromise and tragedy? Through close textual analysis and examination of character trajectories, this study reveals shared characteristics between the two narratives: both characters remained long dependent on male authority within their households and underwent a transformative journey from "fantasy to disillusionment"; yet, their ultimate choices diverged markedly. Upon recognizing her husband's true nature, Nora courageously stormed out, achieving spiritual liberation, whereas, despite exposing the hypocrisy of Zhou Puyuan and others amid anguish, Lu Shiping failed to break free from societal and psychological constraints, ultimately meeting a tragic end through endurance. These disparities cannot be simply attributed to individual character strengths but are deeply rooted in distinct social institutions, family ethics, and the external resources available to women in each culture. The contrast between Nora's choice of escape and Lu Shiping's compromise reflects the underlying sociocultural foundations shaping their divergent destinies.
References
- Simone de Beauvoir. (1949). The First Nature. Galima Publishing House, Paris.
- Chen Rui. (2026). An interpretation of the female existential situation in "Possession" from Foucault's perspective of power [J]. Journal of Henan Polytechnic University (Social Sciences Edition), 27(2): 73-78+100.
- Huan Liu. (2011) Nora and Zijun's Struggle to Escape the Status of Dolls: A Comparison of The Doll's House and In Memoriam [J]. Jiannan Literature (Classic Teaching Garden), (8): 31-33.
- Pierre Bourdieu. (2002). Translated by Liu Hui. "The Domination of Men". Shenzhen: Haitian Publishing House.
- Meirong Guo. (2024). A Brief Discussion on the Similarities of Female Characters in "A Doll's House" and "Thunderstorm"—A Case Study of Nora and Lu Shiping [J]. Language, Mathematics, and Foreign Language Learning (High School Edition, Early Issues), (2): 20-21.
- Zhanmin Tian. (2008). Character Analysis of Nora in A Doll's House [J]. Anhui Literature (Second Half), (4): 194-195+198.
- Qiu Xie. (2018) What Happened After Nora Left?—A New Interpretation of Lu Xun's Conclusion [J]. Cultural Journal, (8): 70-72.
- Wei Wu. (2025). From Family Constraints to Self-Awakening: The Fate Choices of Female Characters in "A Doll's House" and "The Beijing People". Drama Home, (10): 34-37.
- Zheng Kou. (2003) The Construction and Reflection of Female Personality in China's Traditional Ethical Thought [J]. Journal of the Shanxi Provincial Committee of the Communist Party of China, (3): 66-68.
- Hansheng Zheng. (2008). On Nora's Departure in Ibsen's A Doll's House [J]. Journal of Hubei Radio and Television University, (2009): 57-59.