The Collapse and Rebuilding of K-POP Idols' Persona
Abstract
This study focuses on the "anti-scandal system" in the K-POP industry—a mechanism to mitigate reputational damage caused by scandals—and addresses challenges such as global reputational risks and the social media-driven spread of scandals. Adopting mixed research methods, it combines case studies (e.g., the withdrawal of Ju Haknyeon from THE BOYZ and the persona building of NewJeans) with a questionnaire survey (180 valid responses, with respondents primarily being students aged 18-25) to explore the operation of this system and its impact on idol-fan relationships. Findings reveal that idol personas have gradually undergone a strategic shift: for instance, from "divine idols" to "human partners," emphasizing authenticity and modularization to enhance resilience against scandals. Capital-driven risk control measures—including strategic rotation across transnational markets (e.g., adjustments to regional strategies by S2 Entertainment following KISS OF LIFE's racial controversy) and legal-cum-PR tactics—effectively mitigate damage. Questionnaire results indicate that 62.5% of respondents evaluate scandals based on their severity, while only 22.98% disapprove of all the idol's mistakes, reflecting the audience's hard bottom lines and limited tolerance. This study uncovers the characteristics of K-POP idols as "human brands" and examines how industry mechanisms, fan psychology, and capital operations collectively maintain idol personas amid scandal crises, offering insights into the evolving governance models in persona management within the cultural industry.
References
- Bang, E. J., Woo, S. D., & Kim, S. Y. (2022). Analysis of types of avatar utilization by K-pop idols and fandom perceptions. Journal of the Korea Multimedia Society, 25(11), 1601-1612.
- Kang, Eunkyo, (2020). Handwritten Apologies of K–pop Idols: Authenticity of Handwriting and Fandom's Identity as Consumer, Feminism and Korean Literature, vol. null, no. 51, pp. 36–71.
- Park, J. (2023). From Cultural Export to Economic Engine: Examining the Role of K-Pop in the Growth of the South Korean Economy. Open Journal of Business and Management, 11, 2198-2214.
- Wang, S. Q., & Liu, H. L. (2024). The paradox of idol charm behind fans' "unfollowing": An exploration of the fan-idol relationship. Journalistic University, (09), 87-102, 120-121.
- Wu, C. C., & Gu, M. M. (2023). Idol scandals and the psychopolitics of popular culture. Literary Theory and Criticism, (03), 158-168.
- Son, B. Y. (2024). The influence of idol human brand characteristics on consumer attitudes and behavioral intentions. Unpublished master's thesis, Graduate School of Arts, Chung-Ang University, Seoul.
- Kim, H. Y., & Yoon, T. J. (2012). The operational mechanism of the idol system in Korean popular culture: An exploratory study on the dual structure of idol culture production and consumption. Broadcasting and Communication, 13(4), 45-82.
- Hu, J. N. (2022). Emotional attachment and consumer rationality: A study on 'dating scandals' in the era of the idol industry. Contemporary Youth Research, (5), 49-56.