Communications in Humanities Research ISSN: 2753-7072
Home> Volumes> Volume CHR Vol.54> Article
Research Article

An Inquiry into the Causes of the Discrepancy in Evaluations of Su Shi's Stay in Huizhou and Han Yu's Tenure in Chaozhou

Jun ZouThe Education University of Hong Kong*

* Corresponding author: [email protected]

Abstract

Su Shi's stay in Huizhou surpassed Han Yu's in Chaozhou in terms of duration, literary output, and overall achievements. However, evaluations of the two figures in later times vary significantly. Through painstaking literature research on their works and local historical records, this study endeavors to explore the causes of the evaluative bias concerning Su Shi’s legacy in Huizhou. The findings reveal that the Yuanyou Party Struggle precipitated Su Shi's political downfall, as he was listed on the Yuanyou Party Tablet, ending his career. Socially, his low rank subjected him to strict surveillance, and even got those helping him into trouble, isolating him. Culturally, his works and inscriptions were damaged. In contrast, Han Yu was forgiven when relegated to Yuanzhou and had fewer negative impacts. The privacy of letters made most of Su Shi's achievement records in Huizhou disappear. While his construction of "Two Bridges and One Dyke" in Huizhou West Lake was public and documented, causing later generations to focus more on his West Lake contributions. Hence, Su Shi's achievements in Huizhou were long underestimated.

Keywords: Su Shi's Stay in Huizhou; Yuanyou Party Struggle; Huizhou West Lake; Evaluation Bias
Published: March 13, 2025
DOI: 10.54254/2753-7064/2025.21476
Volume: CHR Vol.54
pp. 58-62
Download PDF

References

  1. Tu Meiyun. (2010) The Study of Su Shi's Academic Prohibition and Its Development from the Perspective of the Yuanyou Party Struggle. Soochow Journal of Chinese Literature, 19: 179-212.
  2. Qin Xiangye, Huang Yizhou. (2006) Supplementary Compilation of the Extended Chronicles of the Comprehensive Mirror for Aid in Government. Shanghai Ancient Books Publishing House, Shanghai.
  3. Xu Xiaowang. (2006) General History of Fujian. Fujian People's Publishing House, Fuzhou.
  4. Su Shi. (1986) The Collected Works of Su Shi. Zhonghua Book Company, Beijing.
  5. Tuo Tuo. (2000) History of the Song Dynasty. Zhonghua Book Company, Beijing.
  6. Chen Bangzhan. (2018) The Chronicle of Song History Events. Zhonghua Book Company, Beijing.
  7. Qu Shouyuan. (1996) The Collated and Annotated Complete Works of Han Yu. Sichuan University Press, Chengdu.
  8. Zeng Zaozhuang, Shu Dagang. (2021) The Complete Works of Su Dongpo. Zhonghua Book Company, Beijing.
  9. Su Shi. (2019) The Collected Works of Su Shi. Yuelu Publishing House, Changsha.
  10. Yang Yiqing. (2008) Huizhou City Chronicle. Zhonghua Book Company, Beijing.
  11. Su Shi. (2019) Supplementary Annotations of Su Shi's Poems. Zhonghua Book Company, Beijing.
  12. Li Xian. (1461) The Grand Ming Unification Record. The Inner Court Publication of the Fifth Year of Tianshun, Beijing.
  13. Yao Liangbi. (1961) The Jiaqing Huizhou Prefecture Chronicle. Shanghai Ancient Books Publishing House, Shanghai.
  14. Mu Zhang'a, Pan Xien. (1984) The Great Qing Unification Record. Shanghai Ancient Books Publishing House, Shanghai.
  15. Liu Huinian. (1881) Huizhou Prefecture Chronicle of Guangdong Province. Chengwen Publishing House, Taipei.