Comparative Study of Modern Music Education in China and the West from the Perspective of Comparative Musicology
Abstract
This paper aims to conduct an in-depth study of modern music education in China and the West from the perspective of comparative musicology, revealing similarities and differences in educational goals, curriculum design, teaching methods, evaluation methods, and teacher training. By analyzing the historical background, practical experiences, and challenges of music education in China and the West, this study explores the impact of cultural, social, policy, and economic factors on music education systems. Using a comparative research method, the study contrasts the main characteristics and development trends in music education between China and Western countries, summarizing their respective strengths and weaknesses. The results show significant differences in the concepts, methods, and practices of music education between China and the West, which not only affect the quality of education but also influence the musical literacy and development of students. Ultimately, the paper provides suggestions for improving music education in both regions, aiming to offer references for future educational practices and policy-making.
References
- Sun T ,Du B .Music Education's Role in Psychological Health and Emotional Development[J].Applied & Educational Psychology,2024,5(4):147-151.
- Wu W ,Tham J ,Khatibi A .Problems and countermeasures in the development of traditional music education in Henan Province from the perspective of inheritance[J].Art and Performance Letters,2024,5(2):128-129.
- Field B B .Trauma-Informed Classroom Management in Music Education: A Literature Review[J].Update: Applications of Research in Music Education,2024,42(3):43-51.
- Snježana D .Cultural Intelligence, Intercultural Efficacy and Age as Predictors of Students’ Musical Preferences – the Role of Intercultural Music Education[J].International Review of the Aesthetics and Sociology of Music,2024,55(1):159-180.
- Purnama T ,Antonio F ,Berlianto P M .Assessing the influence of inspirational value on experience quality and electronic word-of-mouth in non-formal music education settings in Indonesia[J].Management & Marketing,2024,19(2):211-232.
- Barros S ,Marinho H ,Pereira A .Music performance anxiety in Portuguese higher education: Contextual factors, perceptions, and strategies[J].Musicae Scientiae,2024,28(2):287-307.
- Wai-Chung*, Ho. "A comparative study of music education in Shanghai and Taipei: westernization and nationalization." Compare: A Journal of Comparative and International Education 34.2 (2004): 231-249.
- Ho, Wai-Chung, and Wing-Wah Law. "Challenges to globalisation, localisation and Sinophilia in music education: A comparative study of Hong Kong, Shanghai and Taipei." British Journal of Music Education 23.2 (2006): 217-237.
- Yandi, Yang. "Past, Present, and Future: A Survey of Teaching and Scholarship of Western Music in China." Journal of Music History Pedagogy 2.2 (2012): 169-177.
- Merriam, Alan P. "Definitions of “Comparative Musicology” and “Ethnomusicology”: An Historical-Theoretical Perspective1." Ethnomusicology. Routledge, 2013. 235-250.
- Li, Zenglan. "Research on Chinese Music Education from a Multicultural Perspective." Research and Advances in Education 2.9 (2023): 45-60.
- Wang, Cheng. "The Practice of Music Education Reform in Modern China." Advances in Educational Technology and Psychology 5.9 (2021): 163-172.
- Van der Linden, Bob. "Non-Western national music and empire in global history: interactions, uniformities, and comparisons." Journal of Global History 10.3 (2015): 431-456.
- Zhu, Hong, and Zixuan Su. "An analysis on higher music education models in China." Revista de Cercetare si Interventie sociala 63 (2018): 105-130.
- Li, Yuan. "How does the music that students listen to affect their level of musical literacy? Comparative analysis of Chinese students’ musical literacy formed with modern online technologies in the context of music and non-music academic majors." Interactive Learning Environments (2023): 1-15.